UMC bishops meet at border to experience immigration issues
SAN DIEGO – Florida Conference Bishop Ken Carter was among more than 50 leaders who got a firsthand look this
week at the conditions faced by people who live and work near the U.S.-Mexican border as part of the Forum of
Active Bishops' meeting.
Carter was in a group that hiked 1.5 miles through the Tijuana Estuary, one of the last undeveloped areas in
the region that is commonly navigated by immigrants crossing the border into the U.S.
"As we hiked to the border, I imagined the journey of families escaping persecution, searching for a better
life, and yearning for reunion with loved ones," Carter said.
"And as we celebrated Holy Communion, I was reminded that nothing can separate us from the love of God."
The experience occurred as the U.S. Senate Judiciary Committee debates the issue of immigration reform. More
than 50 bishops from across the U.S., Africa, Asia and Europe attended the forum. On May 7, they divided into
four groups, each with different itineraries, to see the reality of life at the border and sharpen their focus
on how The United Methodist Church can be in ministry with border residents.
A loaf of bread for Communion was divided into quarters, with each group carrying a piece of the loaf. At the
end of the afternoon, the four groups converged at Friendship Park for a Holy Communion service, separated by
the border wall – some on the Mexico side and some on American ground.
“Consider what it means to live in poverty amidst great wealth,” said Bishop Minerva Carcaño of the Los Angeles
“Consider the impact on families on all sides of the border. Consider the great mission opportunity that exists
for the church.”
Rev. John Fanestil said that he began serving Communion in Friendship Park in 2008 to stand in solidarity with
families who meet there.
“For some families, it’s the only place they get to see loved ones,” he said.
The visit was a learning experience for the bishops, who met with Mario Lopez, a representative of the San
Diego mayor’s office at San Ysidro and viewed the pedestrian bridge leading into Tijuana. At another stop, they
met with Enrique Morones, director of the Border Angels, a volunteer nonprofit organization that advocates for
human rights and immigration reform through community education and awareness programs.
One group of bishops crossed the border into Mexico to the Plaza del Bordo, an open-air migrant encampment to
distribute health kits to the community. They also visited a ministry of the Methodist Church of Mexico.
“Today was a powerful reminder of the relationship we have with the struggles of migrant people and with
strangers all over the world,” said Bishop Warner Brown of the San Francisco Episcopal Area.
“They're people, they're families, just like families that live here, and many of them are directly related to
people who have been here for centuries.”
Bishop Rosemarie Wenner of the Germany Episcopal Area said the experience reminded her of her homeland.
“I come from a country which was divided through a wall and fences for 40 years,” Wenner said.
“The division of families, the division of the church, sisters and brothers here and there, the division of
neighborhoods – that was exactly the same."
She added that having worship services in border communities demonstrates that "any border does not matter
because we know that God's love is for all people and we work for justice so that families can live together.”
The border visits followed a keynote address from Lt. Gen. James Dubik, a retired Army general who shared
lessons in leadership and change management gleaned from a 40-year military career. He is now a consultant for
the National Leadership Roundtable on Church Management, where he has used his expertise to help the Catholic
Church in the U.S.
The bishops also heard from the Rev. Dr. Martyn Atkins, general secretary of the Methodist Church in Britain.
Atkins said that he was encouraging Methodist leaders to do three things: 1) to tell a new story, talking about
who we are becoming; 2) engage in holy risk-taking, believing that holiness and risk belong together; and 3)
encourage people who take risks, allow them to fail and still support them.
The morning’s worship experience, led by Bishop Patrick Streiff of the Central and Southern Europe Episcopal
Area, focused on the theme, “Come walk with us, the journey is long.” He asked participants to center
themselves around their calling into ministry.